The Day After Tomorrow2004

Directed by Roland Emmerich · 2004 · Movie · 2h 04m

ActionAdventureScience Fiction

Where will you be?

A sudden climate shift throws the northern hemisphere into a new ice age, and a scientist crosses a frozen country to reach his son.

6.9dumb per hour
Facepalm

Lower is better.

3 scenes flagged

1
Guilty
1
Contested
1
Explained

1,630 ratings

3
Scenes flagged
1,630
Ratings
1,040
Dumb votes
590
Explained votes
0
Not scored
Rob
First to flag

Is The Day After Tomorrow dumb?

The Day After Tomorrow scores 6.9 dumb scenes per hour, which puts it in the Facepalm band. Lower is better. 2 of its 3 flagged scenes count toward that score, based on 1,630 ratings.

1 scene is Guilty (most viewers say dumb), 1 Contested and 1 Explained. Explained scenes do not count.

Where does The Day After Tomorrow go wrong?

The most common problems are “Broken science” (1 scene), “Easy solution ignored” (1 scene) and “Ignores obvious danger” (1 scene).

Is it worth watching if I hate “Broken science”?

1 of 3 flagged scenes are tagged “Broken science”. It shows up regularly. The highest rated one is How could a superstorm flash-freeze New York in a matter of hours?.

Is it worth watching if I hate “Easy solution ignored”?

1 of 3 flagged scenes are tagged “Easy solution ignored”. It shows up regularly.

Scenes in The Day After Tomorrow

Reviews

On the scene

How could a superstorm flash-freeze New York in a matter of hours?
rocketry_rob8/10AI rewriteOct 30, 2026

Says dumb

The effect is based on a real idea about air at high altitude, but the speed is out of proportion. Nothing in the real climate moves like this.

On the scene

How did Jack walk from Philadelphia to New York in a superstorm?
late_to_credits6/10Oct 24, 2026

Says dumb

The trip is shown as brutal, but the distance and the speed do not line up with the cold the film describes.

On the scene

How did Jack walk from Philadelphia to New York in a superstorm?
harbor_lightsFounding Critic #58Supporter7/10AI rewriteSep 4, 2026

Says dumb

I like the idea and would have been happier with a short note about the route. As it is, the journey is cut to fit the plot.

On the scene

Why did the survivors burn books for warmth in the New York Public Library?
ben_the_skepticSupporter4/10Oct 14, 2026

Says explained

The scene is about what the characters value and how they ration what they have. It is not a puzzle about fuel.

On the scene

How could a superstorm flash-freeze New York in a matter of hours?
late_to_credits6/10Aug 25, 2026

Says explained

It is a disaster film and the timeline is part of the premise. I read the freezing as a heightened version of a risk the film describes.

On the scene

Why did the survivors burn books for warmth in the New York Public Library?
quietcutFounding Critic #12Supporter5/10AI rewriteAug 10, 2026

Says dumb

Wood furniture would burn longer and the film never says why it is not used. It reads as an image that looked good more than a decision.