Prometheus2012

Directed by Ridley Scott · 2012 · Movie · 2h 04m

Science FictionMysteryHorror

The search for our beginning could lead to our end.

A research crew follows a star map found in ancient cave paintings to a distant moon, hoping to meet the makers of humanity.

22.4dumb per hour
Throw the Remote

Lower is better.

7 scenes flagged

5
Guilty
1
Contested
1
Explained

4,561 ratings

7
Scenes flagged
4,561
Ratings
3,619
Dumb votes
942
Explained votes
0
Not scored
Pete
First to flag

Is Prometheus dumb?

Prometheus scores 22.4 dumb scenes per hour, which puts it in the Throw the Remote band. Lower is better. 6 of its 7 flagged scenes count toward that score, based on 4,561 ratings.

5 scenes are Guilty (most viewers say dumb), 1 Contested and 1 Explained. Explained scenes do not count.

Where does Prometheus go wrong?

The most common problems are “Ignores obvious danger” (3 scenes), “Out of character” (3 scenes) and “Plot hole” (3 scenes).

Is it worth watching if I hate “Ignores obvious danger”?

3 of 7 flagged scenes are tagged “Ignores obvious danger”. It shows up regularly. The highest rated one is Why did Millburn try to pet the snake-like alien?.

Is it worth watching if I hate “Out of character”?

3 of 7 flagged scenes are tagged “Out of character”. It shows up regularly. The highest rated one is Why did Millburn try to pet the snake-like alien?.

Scenes in Prometheus

Reviews

On the scene

Why did Vickers and Shaw run in a straight line from the falling ring?
quietcutFounding Critic #12Supporter10/10AI rewriteNov 11, 2026

Says dumb

Anyone who has seen a rolling object knows to move sideways. Several seconds pass in the scene where they could have done that, and the film frames it as suspense.

On the scene

Why did Millburn try to pet the snake-like alien?
quietcutFounding Critic #12Supporter9/10AI rewriteNov 8, 2026

Says dumb

The creature shows clear threat behavior. A biologist would keep distance, and the film gives no sign Millburn is unusually careless before this point.

On the scene

How could Shaw run around after an emergency surgery?
dr_halloranVerified expert: Emergency medicineSupporter8/10Nov 7, 2026

Says dumb

A caesarean-style abdominal surgery with staples and no recovery period would leave a person unable to stand without serious pain, never mind run. The film acknowledges the pain, but not the limits.

On the scene

Why did Holloway take his helmet off on an alien planet?
plothole_peteFounding Critic #7Supporter9/10Nov 10, 2026

Says dumb

The air scan is not the issue. The issue is that the expedition's whole protocol is to stay sealed until the air has been tested over time. Removing a helmet in a place that old is a decision made for the script, not for the character.

On the scene

How did the geologist get lost in a structure he had mapped?
plothole_peteFounding Critic #7Supporter8/10Nov 5, 2026

Says dumb

The film makes Fifield's mapping the central skill he brings. Getting lost with a complete map in hand is a contradiction the story never resolves.

On the scene

Why did Vickers and Shaw run in a straight line from the falling ring?
nopeanut_ninaSupporter9/10Oct 24, 2026

Says dumb

Panic is plausible, but there is time for at least one of them to notice. It reads as a way to produce a death rather than a mistake any person would make.

On the scene

Why did Holloway take his helmet off on an alien planet?
nopeanut_ninaSupporter8/10AI rewriteOct 30, 2026

Says dumb

Holloway wants to be the first person to see an alien world without a visor. That motive is clear, but it still runs against what an experienced explorer would do, and the film does not address the risk.

On the scene

Why did David put the black liquid in Holloway's drink?
canon_keeperFounding Critic #3Supporter4/10Nov 1, 2026

Says explained

David is shown as curious and loyal to Weyland. The film leaves his motive open, but it is plausible he is testing the substance on a person on Weyland's behalf.